| 2004 McDonald's All-American Team (EAST) |
| Rk | Pos | Name | Ht/Wt | Home |
| 1 | SF | Corey Brewer | 6-7/170 | (Portland HS) Portland, TN |
| top defensive wing in the class; put up outstanding sr. year numbers |
| 2 | SF | Rudy Gay | 6-8/215 | (Archbishop Spalding) Severn, MD |
| gradually blossoming into a big force; sky is the limit for him |
| 3 | C | Dwight Howard | 6-11/225 | (SW Atlanta Christian) Atlanta, GA |
| undisputed top player in this class; one of the best in recent years |
| 4 | PF | Al Jefferson | 6-9/265 | (Prentiss HS) Prentiss, MS |
| "Big Al" is big time; monster season with ridiculous scoring totals |
| 5 | C | Randolph Morris | 6-11/270 | (Landmark Christian) Fairburn, GA |
| like Gay, he's coming into his own; shown flashes of greatness |
| 6 | PG | Rajon Rondo | 6-1/155 | (Oak Hill Academy) Mouth of Wilson, VA |
| no one worked harder during the year to make this team; late steal |
| 7 | SG | J.R. Smith | 6-5/210 | (St. Benedict Prep) Newark, NJ |
| skywalking athlete will factor into the dunk contest; rythym shooter |
| 8 | SF | Josh Smith | 6-8/195 | (Oak Hill Academy) Mouth of Wilson, VA |
| blessed with boat loads of ridiculous athleticism; loves to run the floor |
| 9 | PG | Sebastian Telfair | 5-11/170 | (Lincoln HS) Brooklyn, NY |
| child prodidy finally reaches the high point of his prep career |
| 10 | PG | Darius Washington | 5-11/160 | (Edgewater HS) Orlando, FL |
| might be the hardest of the high school guards to defend man-to-man |
| 11 | PF | D.J. White | 6-8/225 | (Hillcrest HS) Tuscaloosa, AL |
| works hard, loves to get it done inside and can step & hit mid-range J |
| 12 | PF | Mike Williams | 6-7/215 | (Wilcox Central HS) Camden, AL |
| a terrific athlete at the four spot blessed with bounce and a live body |